Serves 10
This is one of my late mother, Nellie Jooste’s, very best traditional South African recipes. The venison needs to be marinated for 1 to 2 days beforehand to tenderize it. The lamb is added to ‘tone down the strong flavour’, and if you are making your own pastry it is best made the day before.

You will need

1.5 kg-2 kg venison shoulder (in one piece)
1 cup (250 ml) buttermilk
1-2 lamb knuckles
2 T (30 ml) canola oil
Ina Paarman’s Garlic & Herb Seasoning
4 cups (1 litre) water
2½ T (37.5 ml) Ina Paarman’s Vegetable Stock Powder
1 onion, chopped
10 whole cloves
2 bay leaves
1 t (5 ml) ground coriander
1 T (15 ml) Ina Paarman’s Seasoned Sea Salt Seasoning
2 onions, chopped
½ t (2,5 ml) Ina Paarman’s Green Onion Seasoning
2 T (30 ml) canola oil
1 cup (250 ml) red wine (Pinotage)
½ cup (125 ml) wine vinegar
1 x 200 ml Ina Paarman’s Ready to Serve Pepper Sauce
1 onion spiked with 4 whole cloves
400 g bought puff pastry or Sour Cream Pastry
½ egg, beaten

Ina’s Tip

Brush the inside edge of the pie dish with egg to ‘glue’ the pastry to the dish. It helps prevent shrinkage.


Remove the tough outer membrane from the meat. Coat the venison with buttermilk and marinate for 1-2 days in the fridge. Dry the meat with paper towel and discard the buttermilk. Brown the lamb knuckles in oil in a large, heavy based saucepan. Remove with a slotted spoon, season with Garlic & Herb Seasoning and set aside.

Brown the venison in the same pot, then remove, set aside and Season. Add the rest of the ingredients to the saucepan and bring to the boil. Add the browned meat, cover with a tight-fitting lid and simmer gently until the meat is tender and begins to pull away from the bone (3-4 hours), or cover with foil or greaseproof paper and bake one shelf below the middle in a slow oven, 160°C, also 3½-4 hours. Cool, flake meat, remove bones and reserve gravy.

To make the sauce, sauté the onions pre-seasoned with Green Onion Seasoning in fresh oil until soft and golden. Add the wine and vinegar and boil rapidly over a very high heat until only about ½ cup (125 ml) of liquid remains. Add the reserved gravy and Pepper Sauce. If there is less than 2½ – 3 cups (625ml – 750 ml) of sauce, add more water. Taste and adjust the seasoning. Add the flaked meat.

Spoon the filling into a large pie dish. Wedge the onion spiked with 4 cloves down in the middle of the dish to support the pastry. Cover with a layer of pastry, brush with egg, decorate with pastry strips, also brushed with egg. (It will freeze well up to this stage). Bake at 200°C for 45 minutes. A frozen pie must be left to defrost, covered with clingfilm, to prevent moisture on the pastry. Bake for 10 minutes longer if still cold when it goes into the oven.